Why Children Compare Themselves To Other Children (And How To Stop It)
Have you noticed this in your class?
A child finishes his work, looks at his friend's book and says, "Mummy, why is Tolu's work finer than mine?" Another child says, "Aunty, why did you give Emeka a star and you did not give me?"
Children compare themselves to others. But who taught them to compare?
Let me share what I see in my class.
I have a pupil - let's call her Blessing. Blessing is very good at drawing, but she is slow in writing. Every time she finishes writing, she looks at Tolu's book. If Tolu's work is finer, Blessing will tear her own paper and say, "My own is ugly."
One day I asked her, "Blessing, why did you tear your work?" She said, "Because Tolu's own is finer than my own."
That day I understood - Blessing does not hate her work. She hates that her work is not like Tolu's work.
We teach them to compare without knowing.
Here are 7 ways we teach children to compare, and how to stop it:
1. When We Say "Why Can't You Be Like Tolu?"
This is very common. "Look at Tolu, he has already finished. Why have you not finished?" When we say that, we are telling the child "Tolu is better than you."
Instead, say: "Blessing, you are doing well. Take your time. Your own work is special."
2. When We Clap Only For One Child
If only Tolu gets claps, stars and biscuits, other children will think, "To be loved, I must be like Tolu."
Clap for effort. "Blessing, you tried. Good job! Tolu, you too, good job!" Every child needs encouragement.
3. When We Announce Scores Publicly
"Who scored 10 over 10? Stand up!" The child who scored 5 will bow his head. He will start hating himself.
Instead: Mark privately. Praise privately. "Blessing, you moved from 4 to 6. You are growing!"
4. When We Compare Teachers
"Your former teacher was better." Children hear that. If we compare teachers, they learn to compare friends.
Teach them: Every teacher teaches differently, just like every child learns differently.
5. When We Compare Them At Home
"Your cousin in Lagos has A1, you have C5." This breaks a child's heart. Home should be a safe place, not a competition ground.
At home say: "Your cousin is good. You too are good in your own way. Let's work on yours."
6. When We Display Only The "Best" Work On The Wall
If only Tolu's drawing is on the wall every time, Blessing will think, "My own is not good enough to be on the wall."
Display all work in rotation. Today is Blessing's, tomorrow is Tolu's. Every child deserves to be on the wall.
7. When We Forget To Tell Them "You Are Unique"
God did not create two Blessings. Blessing's fingerprint is different. Blessing's drawing is different. That difference is her power.
Tell children daily: "You are not Tolu. You are Blessing. And Blessing is enough."
Conclusion:
Blessing stopped tearing her paper when I stopped comparing her.
Now when she finishes, I say, "Blessing, show me your special work." She smiles.
No child was born comparing. We teach them to compare by how we praise, how we mark, and how we talk.
Let's teach them to celebrate each other instead.
Let's raise children who say "Well done, Tolu!" and still say "I love my own work too."
---
Tags: why children compare, stop comparison in classroom, inclusive classroom Nigeria, self esteem in children, primary school teachers
Why Children Compare Themselves To Other Children (And How To Stop It)Have you noticed this in your class?A child finishes his work, looks at his friend's book and says, "Mummy, why is Tolu's work finer than mine?" Another child says, "Aunty, why did you give Emeka a star and you did not give me?"Children compare themselves to others. But who taught them to compare?Let me share what I see in my class.I have a pupil - let's call her Blessing. Blessing is very good at drawing, but she is slow in writing. Every time she finishes writing, she looks at Tolu's book. If Tolu's work is finer, Blessing will tear her own paper and say, "My own is ugly."One day I asked her, "Blessing, why did you tear your work?" She said, "Because Tolu's own is finer than my own."That day I understood - Blessing does not hate her work. She hates that her work is not like Tolu's work.We teach them to compare without knowing.Here are 7 ways we teach children to compare, and how to stop it:1. When We Say "Why Can't You Be Like Tolu?"This is very common. "Look at Tolu, he has already finished. Why have you not finished?" When we say that, we are telling the child "Tolu is better than you."Instead, say: "Blessing, you are doing well. Take your time. Your own work is special."2. When We Clap Only For One ChildIf only Tolu gets claps, stars and biscuits, other children will think, "To be loved, I must be like Tolu."Clap for effort. "Blessing, you tried. Good job! Tolu, you too, good job!" Every child needs encouragement.3. When We Announce Scores Publicly"Who scored 10 over 10? Stand up!" The child who scored 5 will bow his head. He will start hating himself.Instead: Mark privately. Praise privately. "Blessing, you moved from 4 to 6. You are growing!"4. When We Compare Teachers"Your former teacher was better." Children hear that. If we compare teachers, they learn to compare friends.Teach them: Every teacher teaches differently, just like every child learns differently.5. When We Compare Them At Home"Your cousin in Lagos has A1, you have C5." This breaks a child's heart. Home should be a safe place, not a competition ground.At home say: "Your cousin is good. You too are good in your own way. Let's work on yours."6. When We Display Only The "Best" Work On The WallIf only Tolu's drawing is on the wall every time, Blessing will think, "My own is not good enough to be on the wall."Display all work in rotation. Today is Blessing's, tomorrow is Tolu's. Every child deserves to be on the wall.7. When We Forget To Tell Them "You Are Unique"God did not create two Blessings. Blessing's fingerprint is different. Blessing's drawing is different. That difference is her power.Tell children daily: "You are not Tolu. You are Blessing. And Blessing is enough."Conclusion:Blessing stopped tearing her paper when I stopped comparing her.Now when she finishes, I say, "Blessing, show me your special work." She smiles.No child was born comparing. We teach them to compare by how we praise, how we mark, and how we talk.Let's teach them to celebrate each other instead.Let's raise children who say "Well done, Tolu!" and still say "I love my own work too."---Tags: why children compare, stop comparison in classroom, inclusive classroom Nigeria, self esteem in children, primary school teachers